Turf Club Calendar Notices - Week 21

The following trainers were fined €200 in each case for the non-notification of a Veterinary Certificate in accordance with the provisions of Rule 194 (v) (vi):- Mr. Mervyn Torrens for Over Presented (lame) at Down Royal on 7th May; Mr. Gordon Elliott for Don’t Back Down (stiff) at Down Royal on 7th May; Mr. T.G. McCourt for Fearnwood Girl (in season) at Punchestown on 8th May; Mr. J.J. Lambe for Breeze With Ease (soft tissue swelling) at Downpatrick on 11th May; Mr. John Joseph Murphy for Oak (lame) at Cork on 11th May and Mr. T. Stack for Pussycat Lips (in season) at Leopardstown on 13th May.

Killarney Meeting, 14th May 2012

The Stewards authorised the following substitution of rider at this meeting: Mr. J.T. Carroll rode Giveabobback (reserve), trained by Mr. Eugene M. O’Sullivan (sixth race).

108A Irish Stallion Farms European Breeders Fund Mares Maiden Hurdle & The Stewards requested a report from Mr. Roger Joseph McGrath, trainer of the winner Thynetocatcher, regarding the apparent improvement in form of his charge particularly compared with the horse’s previous run at Fairyhouse on the 8th April where she pulled up in the race won by Shadow Eile.
Mr. McGrath reported that he was very disappointed with the mares run at Fairyhouse, but that he was at a loss to explain why she ran so badly. He reported that   nothing came to light following an examination by his Vet after the race. The only possible explanation that he could offer was that she jumped badly at Fairyhouse in a better class race, could not get competitive and lost interest. He said that his mare jumped better today in a lower grade race and this may explain the apparent improvement.
Having considered the report, the Stewards noted the explanations offered.

The Stewards fined Mrs Denise Foster, trainer, €130 for lodging a passport in respect of My Cool Lady, in which the vaccinations did not conform with the provisions of Rule 91. The Stewards allowed the horse to run on receipt of the trainer’s written assurance that the vaccinations were in order.

108B Laurels Bar (C&G) Maiden Hurdle & A.E. Lynch, rider of Giants Quest (AUS), trained by Mr. D.P. Kelly, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that his mount travelled well to the fourth last hurdle where he made a mistake and then weakened quickly. The Turf Club Veterinary Officer reported to the Stewards that Giants Quest (AUS) was found to be lame post race.

F.A. McCurtin, rider of Carraig Brook, trained by Mr. John J. Walsh, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that his mount hung right throughout and eventually ran out.

D.G. Hogan, rider of Let’s Go Mad, trained by Mr. C.F. Swan, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that his mount was pulled up lame. The Turf Club Veterinary Officer reported to the Stewards that Let’s Go Mad was found to be lame post race.

108D Keg Security Tralee Maiden Hurdle & The Stewards enquired into the running and riding (Rule 212) of Wakhan, ridden by B. Hayes, and trained by Mr. John Joseph Hanlon.
Evidence was heard from the rider and trainer concerned.
In his evidence B. Hayes stated that his instructions were to drop his mount out and try to get him to finish out his race, something he failed to do last time out at Limerick when  he was ridden handily. He said he got his mount to settle and the horse travelled well down the back straight. He said he tried to get Wakhan to run on for him in home straight but the horse threw his head up in his face when he asked him to quicken. He said the horse is ungenuine and resents being hit with the whip so he just tried to coax him home as best as he could without resorting to the whip.
In his evidence Mr. John Joseph Hanlon confirmed these instructions and explained the background to this horse. He said he has lots of ability but is ungenuine. He tried blinkers on the horse last time but he resented them. He said he felt the animal ran better today with cheekpieces applied. In addition he said the horse jumped better today over this trip. He also stated that his future aim was to win a race with the horse over a trip of around two miles and six furlongs on goodish ground and to have him ridden a bit more prominently than he was today. He expressed satisfaction with the ride considering how high the horse put his head in the air in the home straight. The Stewards also received a report from the Turf Club Veterinary Officer stating that Wakhan was found to be post race normal.
Having viewed a recording of the race and considered the evidence, the Stewards gave both the rider and trainer the benefit of the doubt while noting the explanations offered.

The Stewards interviewed Mr. B.J. Foley, rider of Flaming Hymn (GB), placed third, concerning his use of the whip (Regulation 10) in the closing stages.
Evidence was heard from the rider concerned.
Having viewed a recording of the race and considered the evidence, the Stewards were of the opinion that Mr. Foley was in breach of Regulation 10 3 in that he had used his whip without giving his mount time to respond.
Having taken his record in this regard into account, the Stewards therefore severely cautioned him.

Ms. M. Flynn, trainer of Blackberryblossom, reported to the Office of the Governing Bodies on Tuesday 15th May that her charge was found to be lame on her off fore post race.

108E McSweeney Arms Hotel Handicap Steeplechase & The Turf Club Veterinary Officer reported to the Stewards that Your Busy, trained by Mr. J.A. Nash, was found to have a slight nasal discharge and coughed once post race.

P. Carberry, rider of Gala Dancer, trained by Mr. Paul Nolan, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that his mount erred at the fourth last hurdle and weakened quickly.

108FDan Linehan’s Bar Hunters Steeplechase & The Stewards interviewed Mr. B. Crowley, rider of The Blarney Rose, placed third, concerning his use of the whip (Regulation 10) in the closing stages.
Evidence was heard from the rider concerned.
Having viewed a recording of the race and considered the evidence, the Stewards were of the opinion that Mr. Crowley was in breach of Regulation 10 3 in that he had used his whip without giving his mount time to respond.
Having taken his record in this regard into account, and his inexperience, the Stewards therefore severely cautioned him.

108G Killarney Racegoers Club Ladies I.N.H. Flat Race & The Stewards interviewed Miss M. O’Sullivan, rider of Mine Sweeper (GB), unplaced, concerning her use of the whip (Regulation 10) in the closing stages.
Evidence was heard from the rider concerned.
Having viewed a recording of the race and considered the evidence, the Stewards were of the opinion Miss O’Sullivan was in breach of Regulation 10 2 (b) in that she had used her whip when her chance of winning or being placed had clearly gone.
Having taken her record in this regard into account, the Stewards therefore suspended her for two race days (28th and 29th May).

Miss J.M. Mangan, rider of Elsie, trained by Mr. J.A. Nash, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that her mount hung badly right throughout and ran out after the bend past the stands. The Turf Club Veterinary Officer reported to the Stewards that Elsie was found to be post race normal.

Killarney Meeting, 15th May 2012

The Stewards authorised the following substitutions of rider at this meeting: P.T. Enright rode According to Lizzy (reserve), trained by Miss Margaret M. O’Sullivan (first race) and replaced B.J. Geraghty (unwell) on Headford Flyer, trained by Mr. Eoghan O’Grady (third race).

109A Irish Stallion Farms European Breeders Fund Beginners Steeplechase & PThe Stewards received a report from Mr. J.R. Banahan, Turf Club Starter, regarding the false start to this race.
Mr. Banahan reported that the refusal of Catleen to race contributed to the false start. As a consequence of this, the Stewards interviewed Mr. Gary Davis, authorised representative of Mr. W.P. Mullins, trainer of Catleen, and informed him that a reoccurrence of such behaviour may render the horse liable for suspension in the future.

The Stewards enquired into the running and riding of Caolaneoin, placed fifth, ridden by T.J. Doyle, and trained by Mr. Seamus Fahey.
Evidence was heard from the rider and trainer concerned.
In his evidence T.J. Doyle stated that his instructions were to pop out handy and do the best he could from there. He said the horse jumped the first few fences very ordinary in third or fourth position, but then carted him to the front. He said his mount hung badly right on the bend past the stands and then made a bad mistake at the first fence down the backstraight. He stated that the horse continued to hang right and jump poorly so, on leaving the backstraight, he eased his mount down because he was having difficulty trying to steer him. He said that he wanted to do what was best for the horse and to ensure he did not fall because it was his first start over fences, but the animal was not tired enough to be pulled up. He stated that his mount passed tired horses in the home straight, but that in hindsight, if he was to ride the race again, he would have pulled him up at the end of the backstraight.
In his evidence Mr. Fahey confirmed the instructions. He said that the horse had schooled well, but that he was disappointed with his jumping today. He said his charge had not hung in his hurdle races and that today’s ground was as good as he had encountered to date. He said that he is a keen going sort at home and expressed satisfaction with the ride considering that the horse jumped indifferently and hung. 
The Stewards also received a report from the Turf Club Veterinary Officer stating that Caolaneoin had sores on his lips but was otherwise found to be post race normal. Mr. Fahey was satisfied that these sores were of no significance as they are normal for this horse.
Having viewed a recording of the race and considered the evidence, the Stewards gave both the trainer and rider the benefit of the doubt, while noting the explanations of Mr Fahey. In addition the Stewards severely cautioned T.J. Doyle to be seen to make more of an effort in future.  

B.J. Cooper, rider of Big Generator (GB), trained by Mr. Paul Nolan, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that he pulled his mount up as he thought the horse was lame, but the animal came back sound. The Turf Club Veterinary Officer reported to the Stewards that Big Generator (GB) was found to be post race normal.

109E Dunloe Handicap & The Stewards interviewed W.J. Lee, rider of Kedleston, placed second, concerning his use of the whip (Regulation 10) in the closing stages. Evidence was heard from the rider concerned.
Having viewed a recording of the race and considered the evidence, the Stewards were of the opinion that W.J. Lee was in breach of Regulation 10 2 (f) in that he had used his whip with excessive frequency.
Having taken his good record in this regard into account, the Stewards therefore severely cautioned him.

109D Irish Stallion Farms European Breeders Fund Median Auction Maiden & The Turf Club Veterinary Officer reported to the Stewards that Lucciola, trained by Mr. P.D. Deegan, was found to be post race normal.

109F Killarney Vintners Handicap & The Stewards enquired into an incident (Rule 214) shortly after leaving the stalls involving Whitethorne Scent (GB), ridden by P.J. Smullen, placed second, Can We Dare, ridden by D.P. McDonogh, Our Nana Rose, ridden by A.P. Thornton, and Hangar Five, ridden by F.M. Berry, all unplaced, after it appeared that Can We Dare and Nana Rose both suffered interference.
Evidence was heard from the riders concerned.
Having viewed a recording of the race and considered the evidence, the Stewards were of the opinion that F.M. Berry was in breach of Rule 214 in that he had ridden carelessly.
Having taken his record in this regard into account, the Stewards therefore suspended him for one race day (31st May).
Mr. S. McDonogh, Acting Steward, absented himself from this enquiry.

The Stewards enquired into two incidents of possible interference in the closing stages. The first incident involved Casela Park, ridden by J.F. Egan, placed third, and Hanger Five, ridden by F.M. Berry, unplaced. The second incident which wascloser to the line involved the winner Mellow Manner, ridden by L.F. Roche, and Casela Park.
Evidence was heard from the riders concerned.
Having viewed a recording of the race and considered the evidence, the Stewards made no alteration to the Judge’s placings but advised J.F. Egan and L.F. Roche to ride with more care in future.
Mr. A.J. MacNamara, trainer, attended this enquiry representing Mr. D.K. Weld, trainer and master of L.F. Roche.

D.P. McDonogh, rider of Can We Dare, trained by Mr. Edward P. Harty, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that his mount suffered interference shortly after the start of this race.

Naas Meeting, 16th May 2012

110B Fishery Lane Race & The Stewards enquired into an incident inside the final furlong  involving Tennessee Wildcat, ridden by G.F. Carroll, placed third, and Parliament Square, ridden by J.P. O’Brien, placed fifth.
Evidence was heard from the riders concerned.
Having viewed a recording of the race and considered the evidence, the Stewards were of the opinion that the incident was accidental in nature and they therefore took no further action.

110C Naas Racecourse Handicap & S.J. James, rider of Khaos, trained by Mr. M.D. O’Callaghan, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that his mount became restless in the stalls, jumped awkwardly and unseated him.

The Turf Club Veterinary Officer reported to the Stewards that Royal Visit, trained by Mr. John M. Oxx, was found to be slightly lame post race.

110D Irish Stallion Farms European Breeders Fund Blue Wind Stakes & W.J. Lee, rider of Aloof, trained by Mr. David Wachman, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that his mount ran free in the early stages and may not have liked today’s dead ground. The Turf Club Veterinary Officer reported to the Stewards that Aloof was found to be post race normal.

110F naasracecourse.com Apprentice Handicap & The Stewards requested a report from Mr. W.T. Farrell, trainer of the winner Man Of Erin, regarding the apparent improvement in form of his charge compared to the horse’s previous form.
Mr. Farrell reported that his charge had strengthened up well physically and was gelded since his last run in October. He added that the drop in trip on better ground had also brought about the improvement.
Having considered the evidence, the Stewards noted the explanation offered.

110G Irish Stallion Farms European Breeders Fund Fillies Maiden & The Stewards interviewed Adrian O’Shea, rider of Shirley Schmidt, unplaced, concerning his use of the whip in the closing stages.
Evidence was heard from the rider concerned.
Having viewed a recording of the race and considered the evidence, the Stewards were of the opinion that Adrian O’Shea was in breach of Regulation 10 in that he had used his whip with excessive frequency and without giving his mount time to respond.
Having taken his good record into account, the Stewards therefore severely cautioned concerning his future responsibilities in this regard.

Adrian O’Shea, rider of Shirley Schmidt, trained by Mrs A.M. O’Shea, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that his mount received a kick at the start and sustained a cut as a result.

110H Summer BBQ Evenings At Naas Handicap & C. O’Donoghue, rider of Drinmoy Lad, trained by Mr. Michael McElhone, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that his mount ran out of racing room in the straight.

N.G. McCullagh, rider of Linenhall Lady, trained by Mr. M.J. Grassick, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that his mount reared leaving the stalls and lost ground.

Gowran Park Meeting, 17th May 2012

The Stewards authorised the following substitutions of riders at this meeting: B.A. Curtis rode Theyturnedmedown (reserve), trained by Mr. J.G. Coogan (fifth race); James J. Doyle rode Cannot Give (USA) (reserve), trained by Mr. Patrick Tallis (sixth race) and K.C. Sexton rode Saratoga Baby (reserve), trained by Mr. Peter Fahey (sixth race).

111A Irish Stallion Farms European Breeders Fund Maiden & W.M. Lordan, rider of Mister Aviation, trained by Mr. T. Stack, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that his mount hung right in the straight.

M.C. Hussey, rider of Scotland Forever, trained by Mr. John Patrick Shanahan, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that his mount pulled hard and ducked left in the straight.

111B Irish Stallion Farms European Breeders Fund Maiden & M.M. Monaghan, rider of Cuis Bawn (GB), trained by Mr. Seamus G. O’Donnell, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that his mount hung badly left in the straight.

111C Irish Stallion Farms European Breeders Fund Fillies Handicap & P.J. Smullen, rider of Swerve (GB), trained by Mr. D.K. Weld, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that his mount ran too freely and faded in the closing stages.

111E Gowran Park Golf Club Handicap & F. Lynch, rider of World Ruler (GB), trained by Mr. David Marnane, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that his mount hung left in the straight.

111F Goresbridge Apprentice Handicap & The Stewards interviewed D.J. Benson, rider of Sheilas Wish, placed third, concerning his use of the whip in the closing stages.
 Evidence was heard from the rider concerned in the presence of his master Mr. John C. McConnell.
 Having viewed a recording of the race and considered the evidence, the Stewards were of the opinion that the rider was in breach of Regulation 10, in that he had used his whip with excessive frequency. The Stewards therefore suspended D.J. Benson for two race days (31st May and 1st June) and referred him to R.A.C.E. for a one day tuition on the correct use of the whip.

C.T. Keane, rider of Amhrann Ellen, trained by Mr. William J. Fitzpatrick, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that his saddle slipped in the early stages of this race.

C.M. Walsh, rider of Beart, trained by Mr. J.S. Bolger, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that his mount reared when leaving the stalls.

111G Irish Stallion Farms European Breeders Fund Fillies Maiden & The Stewards enquired into possible interference in the latter stages involving the winner Zariyna, ridden by J.P. Murtagh, and An Saincheann, ridden by K.J. Manning, placed third, after the latter had to check.
Evidence was heard from the riders concerned.
Having viewed a recording of the race and considered the evidence, the Stewards made no alteration to the Judge’s placings. However, the Stewards were of the opinion that J.P. Murtagh had ridden carelessly (Rule 214) and they therefore suspended him for one race day (31st May).

Dundalk Meeting, 18th May 2012

The Stewards authorised the following substitution of rider at this meeting: C.P. Hoban rode Pipers Choice (reserve), trained by Mr. M. Halford (third race).

112A www.dundalkstadium.com Maiden & The Stewards fined Mr. Damien Joseph English, trainer, €130 for lodging a passport in respect of All Ablaze, in which the vaccinations did not conform with the provisions of Rule 91. The Stewards allowed the horse to run on receipt of the trainer’s written assurance that the vaccinations were in order.

112B Irish Stallion Farms European Breeders Fund Maiden & The Stewards enquired into an incident shortly after turning into the straight involving Feathers And Bows (USA), ridden by W.M. Lordan, placed fifth, Wasabi’s House, ridden by J.P. Murtagh, Madamoiselle H, ridden by C.P. Hoban, Tubbertown King, ridden by O. Casey, and Whatyoumaycallit, ridden by N.G. McCullagh, all unplaced, after it appeared that Madamoiselle H, and Tubbertown King, both suffered interference.
Evidence was heard from the riders concerned.
Having viewed a recording of the race and considered the evidence, the Stewards were of the opinion that the interference caused was accidental in nature and as a result of general bunching and they therefore took no further action.

S.H. James, rider of Regal Power (GB) trained by Mr. Edward Lynam, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that his mount hung left in the home straight.

W.J. Lee, rider of Dancingwithangels, trained by Ms. Joanna Morgan, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that his mount became unbalanced twice in the home straight when Regal Power (GB) hung into his horse. He also said that his mount stayed on under hands and heels in the closing stages.

The Stewards informed Ms. Ann R. Reilly, trainer of Apple Be Lucky, that her charge would have to be re-certified before being declared to run from stalls again.   

112E Louth Agricultural Show 17th June Handicap & The Stewards interviewed Mr. John C. McConnell, trainer of Arabela, concerning the withdrawal of his charge from this race for refusing to load which was the third occasion that this animal had to be withdrawn for the same reason.
Evidence was heard from the trainer concerned.
In his evidence Mr. McConnell stated that he bought this filly fully aware of her history and knew that she had been withdrawn on two occasions when in the care of another trainer. However, he said the filly had not caused any problems for him at home or in two runs to date.
Having considered the evidence, including the fact that this was the first occasion Arabela had been withdrawn while under his care, the Stewards advised the trainer that a repeat performance could render the filly liable for suspension. Furthermore, the Stewards suggested to Mr. McConnell that he seek permission from the Stewards to send someone familiar with the horse to the start in future to lead her in.

The Stewards informed Ms. Margaret Mullins, trainer of Pepparpot, that her charge would have to be re-certified before being declared to run from stalls again.

112F(i) Dundalk Stadium On Facebook Handicap (Division One) & The Stewards interviewed R. Dawson, rider of College Sam, unplaced, concerning his use of the whip (Regulation 10) in the closing stages.
Evidence was heard from the rider concerned.
Having viewed a recording of the race and considered the evidence, the Stewards were of the opinion that R. Dawson was in breach of Regulation 10 2 (a) in that he had used his whip in the forehand position in front of the saddle.
Having taken his good record in this regard into account, they therefore severely cautioned him. Furthermore, the Stewards advised R. Dawson to familiarise himself with the Rules concerning the use of the whip.

F. Lynch, rider of Bessie Lou, trained by Mr. Michael Joseph Fitzgerald, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that his mount ran keen and hung right into the first bend.

112F(ii) Dundalk Stadium On Facebook Handicap (Division Two) & C.D. Hayes, rider of Hassanali, trained by Mr. J.T. Gorman, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that his mount was badly hampered on the bend into the straight and was struck into.

Wexford Meeting, 19th May 2012

The Stewards authorised the following substitutions of riders at this meeting: I.J. Brennan rode Fleeting Moment (reserve), trained by Mr. Patrick Martin (second race) and D.M. Grant rode Golden Clubs (reserve), trained by Mr. John Joseph Hanlon (fourth race).

113A Irish Stallion Farms European Breeders Fund Median Auction Fillies Maiden & The Stewards fined Mr. A. Oliver, trainer, €130 for lodging a passport in respect of Shamora (FR), in which the vaccinations did not conform with the provisions of Rule 91. The Stewards allowed the horse to run on receipt of the trainer’s written assurance that the vaccinations were in order.

113B Campile Apprentice Handicap & L.F. Roche, rider of World Ruler, trained by Mr. David Marnane, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that his mount was last for most of the way, hung left and changed legs. He also reported that his mount stumbled in the straight and needs quicker ground.

113C Barrow Rated Race & The Turf Club Veterinary Officer reported to the Stewards that Sinetta, trained by Mr. M. Halford, was found to be post race normal.

113D Black Point Handicap & The Stewards requested a report from Mr. T. Stack, trainer of the winner Time Of My Life, regarding the apparent improvement in form of his charge compared with the horse’s only previous runs at the Curragh on the 9th October and at Dundalk on both the 14th and 28th October 2011, after which the animal was allotted the minimum rating.
Mr. Matt Crosse, travelling head man for Mr. Stack, reported that this colt was a weak two year old that ran at the end of the flat season over varied distances. He said the colt strengthened over the winter and had been working very well lately over a mile and in the company of other successful horses in the stable. He added that it is almost seven months since the horse’s last outing and the yard’s recent runners have been running very consistently.
Having considered the report, the Stewards noted the content.
Mr. T. Stack, trainer, was fined €130 for a breach of Rule 147 (v) in that he failed to lodge the appropriate form appointing an Authorised Representative to represent him in his absence.

Limerick Meeting, 20th May 2012

The Stewards authorised the following substitutions of riders at this meeting: M.J. Bolger rode Lady Sunshine (reserve), trained by Mr. J.F. O’Shea (third race) and replaced R.M. Power (unwell) on Just Moscow, trained by Mrs John Harrington (sixth race); A.P. Crowe rode Rowanville Lady (reserve), trained by Mr. C. Roche (fourth race), B.J. Cooper replaced R.M. Power (unwell), trained by Mrs John Harrington (fifth race) and J.A. McGarvey replaced Mr. C.J. Sweeney (injured) on Our Native Land, trained by Mr. P. Hughes (eighth race).

The Stewards fined the following trainer €200 in respect of his non-runner: Mr. Edward Cawley for Silver Duchess (transport difficulties).

114A Supermacs Dooradoyle Mares Maiden Hurdle & The Stewards interviewed T.C. Carroll, rider of Spring Hawk, placed second, concerning his use of the whip in the closing stages.
Evidence was heard from the rider concerned.
Having viewed a recording of the race and considered the evidence, the Stewards were of the opinion that T.C. Carroll was in breach of Regulation 10.2(A) in that he had used his whip down the shoulder while in the forehand position.
 Having taken his excellent record in this regard into account, the Stewards severely cautioned him for the future. 

M.N. Doran, rider of Knock Na Shee, trained by Mr. Paul Nolan, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that his mount ran very green.

114B(i) Limerick G.A.A. Handicap Hurdle (Division One) & B.J. Cooper, rider of Good Time In Milan, trained by Mr. Donal Aidan O’Brien, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that his saddle slipped in this race.

M.J. Ferris, rider of Aviatore (GER), trained by Mr. David Edward Finn, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that his mount was held up in the early stages as the horse had not run for some time. He further reported that the horse stayed on well past tired horses in the closing stages.

114B(ii) Limerick G.A.A. Handicap Hurdle (Division Two) & The Stewards requested a report from Mr. D.G. Hogan, trainer of the winner Cerveza Dinero (GB), regarding the apparent improvement  in form of his charge compared with the horse’s recent hurdle runs at Navan on 31st March where he finished 13th of 16 finishers and was beaten 34 lengths and at Limerick on 18th March where he finished 12th of 15 finishers and was beaten 55 lengths.
Mr. Hogan reported that at Navan his charge was unable to get competitive over the two mile trip which he felt was inadequate, while at Limerick the horse was unable to handle the heavy ground. In his opinion a combination of today’s more favourable trip and ground conditions brought about an improved performance.
Having considered the report, the Stewards noted the explanations offered.

The Stewards requested a report from Mr. Barry Murphy, representing Miss Elizabeth Doyle, trainer of Reynor (FR), placed second, regarding the apparent improvement in form of the horse compared to his previous run at Ballinrobe on 1st May where he finished 10th of 13 finishers and was beaten 72 lengths.
Mr. Murphy reported that the horse has lacked jumping confidence since a bad fall over hurdles last year and added that the animal jumped poorly at Ballinrobe last time. Today, however, he said the horse jumped with more confidence on better ground. He added that this, in his opinion, brought about an improved performance.
Having considered the report, the Stewards noted the explanations offered.

Andrew J. McNamara, rider of Dunroe Boy, trained by Mr. John G. Carr, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that his mount was slow to get into his stride and met with interference during the race.

114C Join The Tote Go Racing Club Handicap Hurdle & The Stewards requested a report from Mr. Philip Heenan, representing Mr. C.F. Swan, trainer of the winner Zaralabad, regarding the apparent improvement in form of the horse compared with his previous run at Cork on 8th April where he finished 12th of 15 finishers and was beaten 49 lengths.
Mr. Heenan reported that the horse jumped poorly at Cork last time and had been schooled intensively since then. He added that this was a horse with a lot of ability and said that, in his opinion, today’s much improved jumping display brought about the improved performance.
Having considered the report, the Stewards noted the explanation offered.

114D Supermac’s Drive Thru Beginners Steeplechase & Andrew J. McNamara, rider of Survival, trained by Mr. Normal Lee, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that his mount never travelled and jumped poorly.

114F Cul Camps Limerick Handicap Steeplechase & The Stewards requested a report from Ms. Fiona O’Sullivan, representing Mr. A.J. Martin, trainer of the winner Victrix Gale, regarding the apparent improvement in form of this horse compared with her previous run at Downpatrick on 25th March where she finished last of 9 finishers and was beaten 59 lengths.
Ms. O’ Sullivan reported that the horse had been jumping poorly and again failed to get into a good jumping rhythm over two miles and five furlongs at Downpatrick. Today, however, the horse seemed to appreciate the longer trip of three miles and jumped very well. This, in her opinion, brought about today’s improved performance.
Having considered the report, the Stewards noted the explanation offered.
 
Mr. R.P. Rath, trainer of Close Review, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that his charge scoped badly post race.

Navan Meeting, 20th May 2012

115E Irish Stallion Farms European Breeders Fund Maiden & The Stewards requested a report from Mr. James Stack, Authorised Representative of Mr. T. Stack, trainer of the winner Coin Of Courage, regarding the apparent improvement in form of this horse compared with his previous run at Gowran Park on the 12th April where he finished last of seven runners and was beaten 52 lengths by the winner Macbeth.  
Mr. James Stack reported that a combination of better underfoot conditions and a reduction in trip contributed to today’s success.
 Having considered the report, the Stewards noted it’s content.  

115F Irish Stallion Farms European Breeders Fund Fillies Handicap & The Stewards interviewed C.D. Hayes, rider of the winner Jazz Girl, concerning his use of the whip in the closing stages.
Evidence was heard from the rider concerned.
Having viewed a recording of the race and considered the evidence, the Stewards were of the opinion that C.D. Hayes was in breach of R10 (2)(f) in that he had used his whip with excessive frequency. Having taken his good previous record in this regard into account, the Stewards therefore severely cautioned him.

The Stewards enquired into the refusal of East Of Tara, ridden by K.J. Manning, and trained by Mr. J.S. Bolger, to race when the stalls opened.
Evidence was heard from Mr. Gerard Flynn, Authorised Representative of Mr. Bolger.
In his evidence Mr. Flynn stated that this filly is on record for having acted similarly on one previous occasion when in the care of another trainer. He added that she has been recently covered and had shown a slight reluctance to load today which is not her normal form.
Having considered the evidence, the Stewards reminded Mr. Bolger, through his representative, that a recurrence of this behaviour may render the filly liable for suspension.

 C.P. Hoban, rider of Lady Bennett, trained by Mr. C.F. Swan, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that his mount hung right in the straight.

S. Foley, rider of Mojita, trained by Mr. K.J. Condon, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that his mount failed to quicken in the home straight.

115G Come Racing On June 9th Handicap & The Stewards enquired into an incident in the latter stages of this race involving Purple, ridden by J.P. O’Brien, placed third, Me Fere Lady (USA), ridden by K.J. Manning, and Fiery Ambition (GB), ridden by S.M. Gorey, both unplaced, after it appeared that Me Fere Lady (USA) received some interference.
Evidence was heard from the riders concerned.
Having viewed a recording of the race and considered the evidence, the Stewards advised J.P. O’Brien to ride with more care in the future. 
Mr. Peter Reynolds, Acting Steward, absented himself from this enquiry.

The Stewards enquired into possible interference inside the final furlong involving Lord Jim, ridden by S.H. James, placed second, and Filatore, ridden by C. O’Donoghue, placed fourth.
Evidence was heard from the riders concerned.
Having viewed a recording of the race and considered the evidence, the Stewards made no alteration to the Judge’s placings. The Stewards did, however, advise S.H. James to ride with more care in the future.
Mr. Peter Reynolds, Acting Steward, absented himself from this enquiry.